Housing
Justice
Archive



Reading ListOral History Project
Toronto Disaster Relief Committee
1998 - 2012
City of Toronto Archives

The Ontario Coalition Against Poverty
1990 - 2020
Ontario Provincial Archives

Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users (VANDU)
1998 - Present
VANDU Archive / SFU Special Collections


Toronto Homeless Memorial
2000 - Present
   
City of Toronto Archives / Personal Collection / Rebecca Houston

Bob Rose’s Writing
[199- - 20--]
Bob Rose Personal Collection


Oral History Interview Transcripts
(in process)

2025 - Present
timothy martin



timothy martin, Postdoctoral Fellow, Simon Fraser University
timothy_martin [at] sfu [dot] ca


THREE TREES
(Bob Rose)

This is the story of three Christmas trees that live on in memory within a man who worked a drop-in for half of his life. If you don’t know what a drop-in is, let’s just say its a safe social space for poor people, isolated people and anyone else needing someone to talk to, or simply be with. Drop-ins respond to the loneliness carried in the storms of poverty; like hunger, homelessness, personal crisis, or the turmoil of despair, loss and grief. A good drop-in is a place where people support each other, to survive these storms through the sharing of personal experience and welcoming the personal stories which always accompany them.

If you work in a drop-in you must learn how to apply a couple of grounding principles. The first is to how to communicate “You are welcome”- with and without words. The second is to see, hear and create opportunities for people to move from isolation into connection with others. The last is aptitude for making discovery; of the paths to connection, which varies from person to person but comes together in community. Drop-ins are all about building that feeling of belonging which is essential to healing.

I remember a veteran member describing this journey to me one day. He said, “You, know, before I came here, I was so alone that I had nobody in my life except my dancing partner. I called her my dark princess. She came to visit me every day, and we danced the most painful dances you can imagine. But then, the day arrived when she said to me, ‘I am never going to let you go’. So, I ran away, from my home to the streets and to places where I hoped she would not find me. I tell you my boy, she had become the devil. I remember she was wearing a blue dress and out to kill me. But then I found this place and I stopped running. You folks helped me stop running and feel safe again. You listened to my ideas and invited me to contribute to this place. That is what saved my life.”

Over the years I would talk to younger staff about these principles and pathways. Inevitably I would share. “This is the compass I suggest you use to become a good drop-in worker. If you don’t understand the words or if there are no words, but only silence, listen to the tune. Listen and be kind. Be curious. Expect the unfamiliar or unrecognizable. Explore them. And then keep going.

But I digress. This is not the story. It is only the frame within which the story of three trees lives on. It took place on a cold December day, as we began to take up preparations for our annual Solstice Celebration Party. This was, to put it mildly, a unique event, with staff working 24 continuous hours to host a great coming together of the drop-in community on the longest night of the year. Like many things, it was based on members’ response to the question, “What do you want to do in the holiday season?” The answer was, “Why don’t we stay open all day and all night and see what happens?” I asked, “What night would that be?” The answer was dead serious. “The longest night.”

It felt like a wild and crazy idea. Without realizing it we were challenging the longest night with the longest period of darkness by keeping our doors open and filling our space with light and life, food and dancing and surprise events run by various members, from dawn to dawn in tune with the risings of the sun. That experience was so rich it became a tradition, that was renewed every year. What made it so special, apart from being the best party in the neighborhood, was something we had not anticipated. The Solstice took a lot of the sting out of Christmas; with its various humiliations like separation from family and gift giving prevented by poverty. When the Solstice celebration arrived, it softened the worry people felt as they got closer and closer to Christmas Day, because everyone knew there was nothing which could beat the all day and night celebration coming before Christmas arrived. In keeping with this change, the three trees we had traditionally used to mark Christmas period now became the symbols of our upcoming Solstice Party. They were the same kind of trees, but they meant something very different now So, on this one day, in a year I cannot remember, we went out to get our trees. There was fresh snow on the ground and more falling softly, in big billowing, feathery flakes. It was the perfect day for tree finding. As was my custom, with my tie ropes in hand I walked out into the drop-in to ask if there were three members who wanted to come with me to get our three trees. In an instant I had a group of folks standing by my side.

There was Wilfrid, a lovely man. He was deeply respected in our community for the support he gave to others and his readiness to help out whenever or wherever this was needed. There was John, a member artist. When he first began visiting the drop-in, he kept getting into verbal fights with everyone. But he loved to draw, and it seemed to help him calm down, so we gave him his own table and drawing materials. He drew for a year and observed the space. When the first year passed he began to talk without yelling and losing control. And then there was Sheri. I had met her some years before, during her early chaotic visits with us. She acquired a certain degree of notoriety at that time because she would show up every day in bare feet asking for a new pair of shoes. We gave her replacements until we eventually discovered what was in the shoes she tossed away. Then things changed for the better. Sheri moved past that milestone. Now we were gathering Solstice trees together.

When we arrived at the Christmas tree lot, it was mid-afternoon on a weekday. As I anticipated, it was the perfect time for our investigations. Nobody was about. We were the only buyers at that time and it was a beautiful snowy day to boot. I could feel it in my bones. This year’s tree gathering was already becoming precious. We headed towards the tree lot shack and as we walked, I called out to its owner. “Hey Lou, how are you doing. It’s me and my crew, your favourite customers. We have come for our trees.”

There was rustling noise inside the shack and a big, giant of a man appeared in its doorway. He was wearing layered clothing: heavy work pants covered in sap stains, an old, faded flannel shirt complimented by two or three sister shirts, and his work gloves. An old, tattered overcoat flapped open as he shambled down the 3 steps from shack to ground. He dressed like this every year and every year he seemed to get bigger.

‘Hey there my friend! How are ya? How is your drop-in doing? He reached out his hand to shake mine, and then the hand of each person I had brought with me. He was smiling. It’s good to see you my friend. Good to see you all! Tell me, what news do you bring?”

We did this every year. There was no buying until I had shared a few amusing anecdotes with him and he gave me back just as good as he got, telling me about a summer adventure, or giving an update on his trade or family. He always mentioned the quality of his stock every year too (it was always excellent)! His trees were selling well. He seemed to be a happy man. And I said (because it was true) that I continued to tell everyone I knew that he sold the best Christmas trees they would ever buy. That is why I had been finding trees with him, for so many years. He looked around at the group and then turned to me “So, my friend, will it be the same order as last year?”

I said, “Yeah Lou, you know exactly what we want. The largest tree we can find for the main drop-in space. It’s for dancing. A medium sized tree is for the second floor’s quiet area. It’s for talking. And the last, the small tree, goes into the smoking room - where I will decorate it with cigarettes from time to time - before we open. You know that makes for a smooth opening. But it also represents our ability to convert vast clouds of smoke into community development activity.” Lou laughed. He asked the same question every year and I gave him the same answer. He said, “Ok then, let’s go!

I looked at the drop-in members and smiled. I said to them, “Ok let’s go!” Lou escorted us to the trees he knew we wanted. We began our search for the biggest tree in the lot. I gave my team their work gloves and they took up their roles, helping Lou pull out a three large trees for us to take a look at.

The snow continued to fall, making every tree look more beautiful. Lou showed everyone how to give each tree a good shaking so that we could fully see its shape and branching. Then he told them to turn the tree around in a circle so we could view all of it, from front to back. As my group did the holding and turning of the trees, I listened to their discussion of their greater or lesser reasons for selection. They were doing what I had asked them to do, negotiating their way to a consensus on what tree would be chosen. Once this process was completed the selected tree was carried to the empty space in the middle of the lot, making ready for the trunk cutting and delivery on to the roof of my car.

We moved around the lot, slow dancing with the trees and the falling snow. There was no rush. There were no other customers and we had Lou’s full attention. It took a bit more time to choose the medium size tree, perhaps because it was less spectacular than the big one. Or perhaps it was because my group was really beginning to enjoy searching through the trees, pulling them out, shaking them down and building their tree selection expertise.

Finally, we reached the end of this little adventure, coming to the place where the smallest trees were stored. My team kept pulling trees out and putting them back. It seemed odd, but they were having the hardest time choosing this last tree. They looked at eight, until finally they pulled one out from its brothers and sisters which they all agreed on. That was the moment I thought I heard the sound of singing as we placed it with our other chosen trees. A strange thought came into my mind – that we were choosing the father, mother and child of a tree family, and somehow, unconsciously, were re-uniting them – and they were singing.

The members of the team stepped forward and with Lou’s help raised each of them again to their full height, standing them beside each other in a row that went from the tallest to the smallest. I heard someone on the team sing out. “Wow, they are so beautiful! It is going to be a great Solstice this year.”

Lou said, “Good trees folks.”

We lay the three trees down on the ground for cutting them, and then we waited because no one made a move after that. We just stood there, looking down at our trees, admiring them in silence, as the snow continued to fall. It felt like a dream. I looked at the faces of the people who had come with me on this day. They looked younger, as if in this moment, they had become clear of the worry and apprehension that was such a normal part of their daily life. I looked up at the sky. It had not changed. The falling snow was still coming down but the flakes had grown bigger.

Then I heard Lou speak again in a loud and generous voice. “Hey there folks, would you all like a cigar?”

Now this was new. It had never happened before, in all of my years of Christmas tree buying. I looked at him with surprise and he repeated the offer with a big smile on his face. He was apparently in the same moment as the rest of us.

I looked at my group to ask them what they wanted to do, but their answer came without any spoken words. They were nodding their heads up and down, up and down.

I looked at Lou and nodded too. Then I said, “Ok, let’s go, let’s do it!” Lou turned around and called out to his helper. “Hey Joe. Bring some cigars out here. We need five. Oh, and bring one for yourself too.” Joe stepped out of the shack’s door way and called back, “Sure thing boss, be right there.” And then he was right there. He disappeared back into the shack came out again and with a leap down the stairs ran over to join us, his right hand full of cigars.

Lou took the cigars, prepped them and handed them out to everyone in our now expanded group. He pulled a large box of matches and moved around our circle lighting everyone’s cigar. When all the cigars were fired, the puffing and exhaling began. No words were spoken except “Thank you” And then we all just stood there, taking deep draws on the cigars and surrounding ourselves in smoke.

I thought, ‘I guess Lou must know my drop-in is the smoking capital of the universe. And that now, with these cigars, we are at the centre of that universe.’

I stood there smoking and observing the surprise and happiness I saw in my group of tree finders standing in the middle of a Christmas tree lot and being covered by the falling snow. We just stood there, smoking and feeling the unusual sensation of this moment. It felt like everyone had entered into a sacred space that could only be sustained with silence.

Then Lou spoke again. “Hey folks! Would you all like a drink?”

I didn’t need to look at my group to know their answer. I knew they were nodding again.

Our entry into the shack was noisy with the sound of boots stomping and the rustle of bodies shaking snow off feet, coats and heads. I had been inside the shack before on my own tree gathering visits. So, what I saw now was familiar. There was the same plywood walls and exposed framing. There was the same copious collection of empty rum bottles, displayed on the two by fours holding the shack together. I smiled again, as I always did, when I saw this secret refreshment, used by old Christmas Tree sellers, to keep themselves warm though the long days and nights of the selling season.

In the centre of the shack there was a small, low to the ground, table made of plywood and milk crates. Around the table there were more milk crates. This was where you sat down to celebrate your purchase if you were the right customer at the right time.

The members hustled to their crates. I took a seat next to Lou while he got out the rum and small paper dixie cups he used to serve his guests. Lou poured a round for all. I looked about me, at this odd group of misfits; for all of us were bent in one way or the other. Then I looked up at the ceiling and I could see that it was disappearing in the cigar smoke fuming up and up into the rafters.

We remained as we had been outside. We were silent, concentrating on the cigars, the rum, and the sensations of warmth being felt in our minds and in our bodies. I noticed how we were all bending low as we picked up our rum and smoked the cigars. And how everybody in that room seemed to be sitting so peacefully within this unexpected sequence of experiences unfolding in our search for three trees.

Then Lou broke the silence. He held his dixie cup high and called out… “Hey, who here wants another drink?” A unanimous “I do” broke the silence. So, Lou poured another round. I had a sip and leaned in close to him. I said, “Lou, tell me, in all your years in the Christmas Tree trade, how many trees do you think you have sold?”

Lou turned to face me with an expression that suggested nobody had ever asked this question. Now I knew he had at least two large lots, maybe more - and had been doing this for at least 25 years. But I was shocked when he made his response. “Well, let me think for a moment.” And he did. I watched him furrow his brow as he began counting the numbers in his mind. Then he gave his answer. “Well, my friend, you know, counting the years and the trade that has been good to me I expect I have sold more than 60,000 trees!”

I was stunned. I looked back at him and said, “Holy mother of god, Lou. That is a whole forest of trees!” Then I looked my tree finding circle. They were holding their cups in front of them as if their arms had been frozen in mid -air. They were all staring at Lou, and I speculated the were all wondering, who is this man? Lou’s response was unforgettable. “Yes, that’s true, but you know they are farmed. Still, it is something to imagine myself walking through a field with 60,000 trees. That might be quite the hike.

I said, “Let’s drink to that. That’s one hell of a hike.” We drank and puffed on our cigars in silence for a minute or so and Lou spoke again. “You know my friend, now that I think of it, something else comes into my mind. Let me tell you something.” He paused for a second to sip some rum and take a few puffs on his cigar. I could see him thinking.

“You know I get all kinds of people coming to my tree lots. There are the rich people. I can tell they’re rich because they head for the biggest trees and they don’t spend any time looking at them. They just grab the biggest tree I have, buy it and leave with hardly a word or thank you spoken. Then I get the folks coming who have some money to spend, but not enough for the big ones. Those folks spend some time with their choosing, asking us to pull out maybe three or four or even 6 trees to look at. They look like they are trying to get the best bang for their buck. Middle money I would say. Then, there are folks coming for the smaller trees. A lot of younger people there. Or folks who are living alone. They have a good look too.

But not for the same reasons. Sometimes it seems that the buying of a tree is the last stage in a debate they have been having with themselves on whether to get a tree or pass on the idea.”

Then he paused, like he had something else to say but was wondering whether to say it or not. I waited. I was sure he was going to tell us something more.

“And then I have another group of people who come in here. You know my friend, they are poor. You know how I can tell they are poor? I know it because of the way they behave in my lot. They spend a lot of time here. Far more than anybody else. They look at and touch all of the trees, from big to small. And then when I ask them if they have found something like, they tell me they love them all but are just looking, because they have no money at all to spend on Christmas trees.” Lou leaned down low to the table and picked up his dixie cup of rum again. He leaned back from his milk crate, took a big drag on this cigar and turned to me to ask, “So you know what I do?”

I said, “No, what do you do?”

Lou laughed. Not a shallow laugh, but a deep belly, full throated laugh. The kind of laugh you don’t share with strangers because it is as personal as a hug or a kiss. And Lou said, “I’ll tell you what I do. I give them a tree. Yes sir. I probably give thirty trees away every year!’

Lou paused for a few seconds and spoke again. “You know why I do that?” He was looking at me as closely as I was looking at him. I glanced over at my crew and saw that they were still listening too.

Lou raised his dixie cup, took a big drag on his cigar, and blew its smoke all over us. And then he softly spoke, “I will tell you why! “What the hell………it’s Christmas….…….isn’t it?”

With that said, he extended his dixie cup out into the space that was now joining us all together and called us to action, “Cheers all”. Then, in perfect time, we downed our rum in unison.

I smiled. And then I sighed inwardly. Thinking, “What a world, what a world, what a world.”